Skip to main content

Map of Shadows

Map of Shadows by J. F. Penn



*I received free copy to review from the publisher in exchange for an honest review*

Synopsis (from Goodreads)
When her Grandfather is murdered under mysterious circumstances, Sienna Farren inherits his map shop in the ancient city of Bath, England. Once there, she discovers that her family is bound up with the Ministry of Maps, a mysterious agency who maintain the borders between this world and the Uncharted.
With the help of Mila Wendell, a traveller on the canals, Sienna discovers her own magical ability and a terrifying place of blood that awaits in the world beyond.
But when she discovers a truth about her past and the Borderlands begin to push through the defenses, Sienna must join the team of Mapwalkers on their mission to find the Map of Shadows – whatever the cost.
In a place written out of history, a world off the edge of the map, Sienna must risk everything to find her father … and her true path as a Mapwalker.

Review
This book had a lot of great elements! It has a very interesting premise. I thought the world and magic system in the book were creative and original. I like the idea of being able to work magic with maps, or of maps having a type of power over the world. The idea of certain people's blood can also be used to strengthen the borders is slightly creepy but creative and really worked with the setting. I also liked the idea about how maps and places change over time, and what happens to those things when they change? The whole concept of the Borderlands was fascinating and I loved the dark and disturbing world Penn created.

Where this book didn't pull through was I felt there just wasn't much depth to it. The story went so quickly, I felt like I didn't really get to know the characters, so I didn't care so much about what happened. The romance felt rushed. The betrayal had no emotional impact. The plot ran at breakneck speed. With Sienna, she decides within a couple hours to accept this whole different world that she never knew existed, and just dives right in. I would have enjoyed to see her struggle a bit more with the transition. A lot of elements were definitely there: romance, sibling love, friendship, adventure discovering a new world and magic. There was even the interesting discussion about maps and borders changing over time!

But it just needed a little more. The book would have benefitted from being 100 pages longer, in building the relationships between characters, driving up the tension, and really bringing the world to life.

Overall, I did enjoy it, and it's good for a quick fantasy read.


Rating
I give this book 3 stars.


Details
Genre: Fantasy.
Language: Mild to none.
Sex: None.
Violence: Some bloody descriptions, plus some scenes of conditions with abused women and children.
Labels:

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

This Savage Song

This Savage Song - Victoria Schwab Review: The newest book by one of my favorite authors, V.E. Schwab (She goes by "Victoria" for her YA novels). I love the premise for the book: violent acts create actual monsters. The two main characters are a human girl named Kate who desperately wants to be a (figurative) monster: a big, bad crime boss like her father, who runs one half of V-City. The other is August, who is a literal monster, a Malchai, one that drains the souls of his victims through his music, who desperately seeks his own personal humanity. I loved them both, and their personalities and characters and drives are so multi-faceted and real. They interact with other characters in believable and different ways. The juxtaposition of these two characters in and of itself is one of the driving things behind this story, and one of the things that makes it so compelling. Even though marketed as a YA, it really delves into the deep questions: What makes us human? W...
Post a Comment
Read more

The Reader

The Reader by Traci Chee Synopsis (from Goodreads) "Sefia lives her life on the run. After her father is viciously murdered, she flees to the forest with her aunt Nin, the only person left she can trust. . . . But when Nin is kidnapped, Sefia is suddenly on her own, with no way to know who’s taken Nin or where she is. Her only clue is a strange rectangular object that once belonged to her father left behind, something she comes to realize is a book." Review The main reason I picked up this book was that it got a LOT of hype. I thought it was a good book, but I'd say more for younger YA. I think if I were 12-14, I would have REALLY loved this book. The premise is interesting: In a world where reading doesn't exist, Sefia has a rare book. However, I found at times the story was a bit too  meta... stories within stories within stories, and how reading is literally magic. The pacing was quite slow. I also found the feel or tone of the story jumped around. Fi...
Post a Comment
Read more

Thursday Themes: So you liked The Hunger Games

So you really liked The Hunger Games and want some more of that sweet sweet dystoptian YA feeling. I'm guessing you've already read Divergent by Veronica Roth and Maze Runner by James Dashner (if not, were you even part of the YA dystopian craze??). Here are some other series I think you'll enjoy: Red Rising by Pierce Brown Basically Hunger Games in Space with super evolved humans. The main character is of the lowest caste (a Red) and fakes his way to the very top of society in order to take them down. ***Content Warning*** This book has a lot of violence (about the same as HG), and there is high use of profanity. Partials by Dan Wells One of the most underrated series in my humble opinion. 99% of the world's population has been wiped out by a weaponized virus during the war with the Partials—engineered organic super-humans—and no new babies are being born. Sixteen year old Kira is trying to find a solution. When a supply run ends with them capturing ...
Post a Comment
Read more